A Brief Introduction
Years in Review
Films Ranked: 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Current Criticism
Search Criticism
Past Criticism
Top 10 Lists
Notable Short Films
Contact Me


Director:  Sam Mendes
Year Released:  2005
Rating:  1.5

Tips you off early on that it's an 'existential' film when the Anthony Swofford character (played by Jake Gyllenhaal) is shown reading The Stranger while trying to deal with his stomach ailments: ultimately, it's shitty Camus. This timely 'anti-politician/anti-war' picture smacks false so often it's distracting: whereas Kubrick - in the fantastic Full Metal Jacket - looked upon the process of becoming and being a Marine with icy calm, Mendes is more of a fabulist, aiming more for symbolism (horses, Gyllenhaal vomiting sand in a dream) and almost Animal House-level rowdiness, and part of me feels that at least Kubrick respected the troops a little more than Mendes, who views the men as a bunch of cartoonish animals channeling their homosexual and homicidal impulses (the ending asks us to pity those that return to their mundane lives). Peter Sarsgaard plays the Gomer Pyle character, tweaked and tragic, but he's barely developed - the same goes for almost everyone else. My father, a Vietnam Veteran and former Marine, insists the book is better, which probably goes without saying (the movies generally act as expensive Cliff's Notes for a time-starved populace).

Return to the Previous Page

© Copyright 2019 Matthew Lotti.