The Mating Season

Director: Mitchell Leisen
Year Released: 1951
Rating: 1.5

Financially unable to continue running her hamburger joint in Jersey City, Ellen McNulty (Thelma Ritter) heads out to Ohio to visit her son Val (John Lund) who just so happens to be getting married to upper-class Maggie (Gene Tierney) - the ex-girlfriend of his boss George C. Kalinger Jr. (James Lorimer) - and then Ellen poses as a maid so she can help the newlyweds.  The poster boasts that it's a comedy but aside from Ritter's smart remarks there really isn't anything directly "funny" about it, and not only is Lund basically a dud as the "leading man," but there are so many contrivances and bizarre decisions made it ruins the movie: who leaves Tierney in an automobile dangling off a cliff?  Who would stay at a company after stealing his employer's girl?  How difficult is to whisper "that's my mother" to his own spouse?  Ritter's blue-collar darling is far too good for this screenplay (which was co-written by Charles Brackett, who should have known better), although she was nominated for an Academy Award for it.  What I need to know is why the brigadier general needed to be kept away from the French telephone: did he make dirty phone calls?  Or was it something naughtier?